The Inn On Madeline Island

We stopped by for drinks and found it to be the perfect spot to relax outside by the water. Nothing like a margarita with your toes in the sand. The outdoor bar was pet-friendly too, which was great for my friend’s large dog. The indoor bar was equally inviting. Though a bit on the pricier side, we loved the atmosphere and the quick, attentive service.

The Inn on Madeleine Island is a wonderful place to stay! Their staff went above and beyond to make our time there special. Our room was very comfortable and clean, overlooking lake Superior. Thank you so much for the great stay! We will be back!

We stopped here for lunch and our food and waitstaff service was top notch. They sat us right away and opened up an umbrella for a nice patio table. The whitefish tacos were great, not too heavy for lunch and seasoned perfectly. My husband’s burger was also perfectly cooked. We played lawn games, enjoyed the beach and a beer. Perfect lunch stop before hopping on the ferry back to Bayfield.

Our daughter got married there over the weekend. It was fantastic! We originally booked the venue when another person at the Inn was managing. (She is no longer there). We were not getting much attention until Julie, the new Pub manager, took over and made it an absolute perfect weekend! Her attention to detail, get it done attitude and kind spirit was the icing on the cake. Julie was the best as well as her awesome staff! Thank you from all of our family. The bride and groom are so grateful for a memorable experience

My wife and I decided to fly up for a last minute anniversary trip and were happy to hear the Inn had a room available. The staff was extremely accommodating and helpful, even providing us a ride back to the airport on the island after our stay. We stayed in the 'bungalows' which were beautiful and private, and were a short walk from the Pub and La Pointe. They also were able to provide us with dining and activity recommendations that turned out to be excellent. The pub at the Inn was the best dinner we had on the island or in Bayfield. We truly wouldn't have had as good of a trip if it wasn't for the incredible service we received. We will absolutely be back to stay again.

We stayed in the Fairway Suites by the golf course over 4th of July Weekend 2024 (Thursday-Sunday). I was a bit scared by some of the bad reviews here, but I have to say that it seems like those people went to a completely different place. The Inn itself is amazing, the pub overlooks the lake and when we arrived it was perfect weather on a mostly sunny evening. The staff was super helpful. We got there late so the front desk staff had left, but self check in was easy. The next day there were two front desk people who were very helpful. The vibe of the Island is amazing, I will be back and I will stay at the Inn. I highly recommend Madeline Island and the Inn anytime you want to stay at a nice hotel in a place the feels way more remote than it really is!

We were up at the Apostle Islands for our Anniversary, the drive was beautiful and the Ferry Ride over to Madeline Island was awesome, but our Cabin rental was a bust. Fortunately, Sharon at the front desk of the Inn On Madeline Island was amazing, nice and extremely helpful! We were able to get into a King/Whirlpool - Lake Front Lux Room for our 3 night stay. It was so comfortable with fluffy bedding, lots of squishy pillows and slippery white sheets. Quite the opposite of the rental we had left. The FOOD at The PUB was also AMAZING. My favorite was the mouthwatering Blackened White Fish Cesar Salad but all the meals were amazing - we just ate there most of the time! THANK YOU to the staff at this amazing place. We got a great deal too. I would highly recommend staying / playing and relaxing at The Inn On Madeline Island!

We stopped at the Pub for dinner and I'll be dreaming of the roasted beet salad with whitefish for a long time. Probably my favorite part of my visit to Madeline Island. Staff and atmosphere were both lovely. Great option for a nice but unpretentious meal.